Skip to content
Home » Most Popular Motorola vs Arris Cable Modem Which One is Better

Most Popular Motorola vs Arris Cable Modem Which One is Better

The latest cable modem products introduced by Motorola are Motorola MB8600 and Motorola MB8611 DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem, while for the latest DOCSIS 3.1 gateway products are Motorola MG8702, Motorola MG8725, and MG8733. Arris is one step ahead with Arris S33 cable modem, G34, G36, and the latest one is Arris G54. How Arris vs Motorola cable modem products perform, which one is better value? 

In This Article:

ARRIS acquired Motorola home in 2013, its popular Motorola surfboard cable modem products line is now under arris surfboard. How does Motorola cable modem products line compete with Arris?  

Motorola vs Arris Surfboard

Both Motorola and Arris introduce two types of DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem devices, the native cable modem (without NAT, network address translator) and the gateway model (the wifi router with built-in cable modem).

Motorola DOCSIS 3.1

There are two types of DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem products offered by Motorola, the Motorola MB8600 and MB8611 DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem, while the gateway models are Motorola mg8702, Motorola mg8725 and mg8733. The last three products are wifi routers with built-in DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem in one compact device.

What is the difference between Motorola mb8600 and mb8611?

Motorola MB8600 vs MB8611

Both Motorola MB8600 and the latest one is MB8611 are DOCSIS 3.1 cable modems with 2×2 downstream / upstream OFDM, compliant to 32×8 Channel bonding DOCSIS 3.0. Technically, these two modems can support downstream internet up to 4.8Gbps from your cable provider. However, the maximum that can be supported depends on your cable modem.

Motorola MB8611 DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem
Motorola MB8611 DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem

Table 1 Motorola Mb8600 vs MB8611

Cable modemMotorola MB8600Motorola MB8611
DOCSIS download speedUp to 1,0Gbps internet planUp to 2.5Gbps
Ethernet Ports1x 1Gbps Ethernet Port1×2.5 Gigabit Ethernet (GigE) LAN port
(supports 10/100/1000/2500 Mbps)
Internet Plan up to1,000Mbps2,500Mbps
Dimension7.8 in x 2.5 in x 7.25 in (200 mm x 57 mm x 184 mm)7.25 in x 2.25 in x 7.88 in (184.1 x 57.1 x 200,1) mm
Weight1.15 lb (523 grams)1.1 lb / 498.9 grams

If you compare these two series with the latest two products offered by Arris, you can find that Motorola mb8600 is comparable with Arris Surfboard sb8200, and the Motorola mb8611 is comparable with Arris Surfboard s33.

See also Netgear cm2000 vs Motorola mb8611

Let’s see what Arris offers to the market recently.

Arris DOCSIS 3.1

So far Arris released two models of DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem; the Surfboard SB8200 and Surfboard S33. While the gateway products released are arris surfboard SBG8300, arris surfboard gn34 and arris 36. Let me take each of them and compare them to Motorola.

Surfboard DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem

There two series of DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem model offered by Arris; the Surfboard Sb8200 and the latest one is Surfboard S33. What are the main differences between these two models? Take a look at the following spec comparison table 1 to help you understand the differences.

Arris Surfboard S33 docsis 3.1 cable modem
Arris Surfboard S33 docsis 3.1 cable modem

Both of the two models support multi network, you can create two separate networks when you subscribe two separate cable internet services for load balance or a kind of failback & failover system. The Arris Surfboard S33 comes with 1x 1Gigabit Ethernet and 1×2.5Gbps Ethernet ports, while the sb8200 comes with 2x 1Gigabit Ethernet ports.

Table 1 Surfboard DOCSIS 3.1 Cable Modem

ModelArris Surfboard SB8200Arris Surfboard S33
Cable technologyDOCSIS 3.1DOCSIS 3.1
Downstream / upstream channels2×2 Downstream / Upstream OFDM DOCSIS 3.1 channels Compatible with 32×8 DOCSIS 3.02×2 Downstream / Upstream OFDM DOCSIS 3.1 channels; Compatible with 32×8 DOCSIS 3.0
DOCSIS download speedUp to 2 Gbps downloadUp to 3.5 Gbps download
Ethernet Ports2x 1Gigabit Ethernet Ports1x 2.5Gbps Ethernet Port
1x 1Gigabit Ethernet Port
Multi network supportYesYes
Dimension5.13 x 1.7 x 5.25 in (130.1 x 43.2 x 133.3) mm5.14 x 1.8 x 4.74 in (130.55 x 45.7 x 120.4) mm
Weight1.59 pounds / 712 grams0.9lb / 408.2 Grams

Today you can find few premium models of wifi 6 routers that come with 2.5Gbps WAN port such as D-link ax6000 wifi 6 router, the new wifi 6e routers such as Asus gt-axe11000 wifi-6e router and the newer models of mesh wifi 6 systems such as Orbi rbk850 and Asus xt8.  

How those products are compared to help you choose which one is suitable to meet your business needs?

Motorola vs Arris DOCSIS 3.1

We see that both Motorola and Arris offer three models of devices based on DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem and available in the market. Let’s see how they are compared.

Motorola MB8600 vs Arris SB8200

Both Motorola mb8600 and Arris sb8200 are DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem you can use for internet plan up to 1Gbps from your cable provider. The main difference between them is sb8200 comes with 2x 1Gbps Ethernet ports but mb8600 only one. Should you like to create two separate private networks, sb8200 is ideal to support your business need.

Take a look at the following table 3 below, both mb8600 and arris sb8200 are docsis 3.1 cable modems delivering upstream 2×2 ofdm and are compatible to 32×8 docsis 3.0 cable modem infrastructure, so do all docsis 3.1 cable modems.

Table 3 Motorola mb8600 vs Arris sb8200 Docsis 3.1

Cable modemMotorola MB8600Arris Surfboard SB8200
Docsis 3.1 Cable technologyYesYes
download speedUp to 1GbpsUp to 2 Gbps download
Ethernet Ports1x 1.0 Gigabit Ethernet (GigE) LAN port
(supports 10/100/1000/2500 Mbps)
2x 1Gigabit Ethernet Ports
Multi network supportNoYes
Dimension7.8 in x 2.5 in x 7.25 in (200 mm x 57 mm x 184 mm)5.13 x 1.7 x 5.25 in (130.1 x 43.2 x 133.3) mm
Weight1.15 lb (523 grams)1.59 pounds / 712 grams

The price difference is around $20, Motorola is cheaper than Arris.

Motorola MB8611 vs Arris S33

If you’ve already had wifi 6 routers or mesh wifi 6 systems in place with multi-gig 2.5Gbps WAN port, while currently your cable modem is still equipped with 1.0Gbps Ethernet port,  you need to replace it with the one that comes with 2.5Gbps Ethernet port. This will deliver maximum data rate throughput between modem and the router only if you subscribe multi-gig internet plan up to 2.5Gbps from your internet provider.   

Which one is suitable to meet your homes need, Motorola MB8611 or Surfboard S33? If you only need to build one single network, Motorola mb8611 is appropriate. However, with Surfboard s33 you can create two separate internet network in homes.

Please note that arris s33 with two ethernet ports doesn’t support link aggregation wan like the one offered by Netgear cm1100 or cm1200. You can find few models of wifi 6 routers support wan aggregation by combining one wan port and one lan port into a teaming port. You cannot use arris s33 for link aggregation, but you can use netgear cm1100 or cm1200 cable modem.

Table 4 below shows you spec comparison table between MB8611 and S33 cable modem.

Motorola mg8702 gateway
Motorola mg8702 gateway
Spec comparison Motorola vs Surfboard

Table 4 Motorola vs Surfboard DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem

Cable modemMotorola MB8611Arris Surfboard S33
Docsis 3.1 Cable technologyYesYes
Download speedUp to 2.5GbpsUp to 3.5 Gbps download
Ethernet Ports1×2.5 Gigabit Ethernet (GigE) LAN port
(supports 10/100/1000/2500 Mbps)
1x 2.5Gbps Ethernet Port 
1x 1Gigabit Ethernet Port
Multi network supportNoYes, but not link aggregation
Dimension7.25 x 2.25 x 7.88 in (184.1 x 57.1 x 200,1) mm5.14 x 1.8 x 4.74 in (130.55 x 45.7 x 120.4) mm
Weight1.1 lb / 498.9 grams0.9lb / 408.2 Grams

See here that the only main difference is the inclusion of another 1x Gigabit Ethernet port in addition of 2.5Gbps one for s33. Since the price difference is not too much, Surfboard s33 is ideal to choose in case you need separate network for experiment or other technical tasks. Read more details for further discussion, see current price and best deals in Amazon (#ads).

Motorola vs Arris Surfboard Gateway

For folks that prefer all-in-one model of cable modem gateway, which is a wifi router that comes with built-in cable modem they may consider one of these DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem with wifi products. Motorola and Arris both introduce two models either based on legacy wifi 5 or wifi 6 standards.  

Motorola offers Motorola mg8702 with legacy wifi5, while Motorola mg8725 is wifi 6-based product. On the other hand arris offers arris surfboard sbg8300 wifi 5 and the recent series are arris surfboard g34 and g36 which are based on latest wifi 6 technology. 

Motorola Mg8702 vs Arris Sbg8300

Both of these two products are still based on legacy wifi 5 standards that are still worth purchasing for homes with bunch of legacy wifi 5 devices (wireless ac devices). Even those wifi 6 devices are compatible in connecting to legacy wifi 5 routers, however not as fast as connecting to wifi 6 ones.

Please refer to table 5 below for spec comparison between Motorola mg8702 and arris surfboard sbg8300, both come with built-in docsis 3.1 cable modem.

Table 5 Motorola Mg8702 vs Arris Surfboard Sbg8300

Cable Gateway modelMotorola MG8702Arris Surfboard SBG8300
Built-in Docsis 3.1 Cable modemYesYes
Wifi technologySimultaneous dual band AC3200 wave 2Simultaneous dual band AC2350
Wave 2
Wifi speedsUp to 2167Mbps @5GHz 4×4 MU-MIMO 
Up to 1,000Mbps @2.4GHz 4×4 MU-MIMO
Up to 1733Mbps @5GHz 4×4 MIMO;
Up to 600Mbps @.4GHz 3×3 MIMO
SSIDs4x SSIDs / 2x each bandPrimary, secondary and guest SSIDs
Antennas4x dual band internal antennas3×3 and 4×4 MIMO antenna arrays
Ethernet Ports4x 1Gigabit LAN Ports  with Auto-MDI/MDIX4 x 10/100/1000 Base-T Ethernet LAN
(RJ-45 connector) MDI /MDI-X
USB Port1x USB 3.0 with DLNAN/A
Dimension9.5 x 2.8 x 8.8 in (241 x 225 x 71) mm2.87 x 8.0 x 9.33 in (72.9 x 71.1 x 236.9) mm
Weight30.43 ounces / 862 grams1.94 lbs / 0.88 kg
Works with AlexaYesYes
Price in Amazon (Jul 2021)$249.99$280.44
Which one is suitable for your business

Motorola MG8702 offers more advantages over Surfboard sbg8300 considering mg8702 is designed with higher speed AC3200 wifi and the inclusion of 1x USB 3.0 for USB disk storage. Moreover Motorola mg8702 is tagged with lower price, not too much actually.

Arris Surfboard sbg8300
Arris Surfboard sbg8300

Click the link below to read more details, current price and deals in Amazon (#ads), and other different products.

These two products are still based on legacy wifi 5 standards with cable modem, what about the products with recent wifi 6 technology?

Motorola Mg8725 vs Arris G34 / G36

With the emerging of wifi 6 products in the market, both vendors Motorola and Arris release the latest product based on this recent wifi technology. Motorola released mg8725 and mg8733 ax6000 wifi 6 products. The difference between the two series is the inclusion of two voice phone ports for mg8733, but mg8725 isn’t.

Motorola mg8725
Motorola Mg8725

What about arris wifi 6 product? The latest products released by arris are arris surfboard g34 and surfboard g36. Both of these two series are the same except g36 is equipped with 2.5Gbps, but g34 is not.

Please note that Arris just released its ultimate product, cable modem with router product based on the next generation of wifi 7 technology. Click here to read Arris G54 BE18000 cable modem router. This product supports multi-gig 10Gbps internet plan and 10Gbps LAN port.

So what is the difference between Motorola Mg8725 and arris surfboard g36? We can use table 6 below to get a better insight between the two product series.

Both products are wifi 6 products with built-in docsis 3.1 cable modem. See that the main difference is the network segment each the product works at. Mg8725 delivers double bandwidth as high as Arris g36, and both are equipped with one multi-gig 2.5Gbps lan port to allow you connect to high speed NAS device for example. However, g36 comes with one more gigabit lan port than mg8725.

Arris surfboard g36
Arris Surfboard G36

If you don’t require multi-gig 2.5gbps port you may consider arris g34, the price is few bucks cheaper than g36. You can refer to the following spec comparison table between mg8725 / mg8733 (with two phone ports) and arris g36.  

Spec comparison Motorola vs Arris G36

Table 6 Motorola Mg827 vs Arris G36

Cable Gateway Model Motorola Mg8725Arris Surfboard G36
Built-in Docsis 3.1 Cable modemYesYes
Wifi technologySimultaneous dual band ax600 wifi 6Simultaneous dual band ax3000 wifi 6
Wifi speedsUp to 1200Mbps @2.4GHz 4×4;
Up to 4800Mbps @5GHz 4×4;
1,200Mbps @2.4GHz; 4×4  
1,800Mbps @5GHz 3×3
SSIDs4x SSIDs (2 SSIDs / radio band )One network name or each band
Ethernet Ports1x 2.5Gbps LAN;
3x Gigabit LAN ports ; with Auto-MDI/MDIX
1x 2.5Gbps LAN Port; 
4x Gigabit LAN ports
Dimension8.8 in x 5.7 in x 3.5 in  (223.5 mm x 144.8 mm x 88.9 mm)10.87 in x 9.92 in x 3.31 in (276 mm x 251,9 mm x 84 mm)
Weight32 Ounces / 907 grams3.15 pounds / 1043 gram
Works with AlexaYesYes

With double bandwidth, mg8725 is more costly than arris g36. To learn more details, click the link below to learn more details the product, see current price and best deals in Amazon (#ads).

Click here Arris g36 in Amazon (#Ad) Or click here to see in Best Buy

Upcoming Docsis 4.0

Today you may find few models of premium products introduced to the market with multi-gig 10Gbps Ethernet port, you can name it new deco xe200 or orbi rbk963. As far as I concerned many people may find it too much having 10Gbps wan port since today the high speed cable modem comes with only 2.5Gbps port. However, you can find fiber optic internet services such as Sonic offers you up to 10Gbps internet service.
Basically this 10gbps wan port is to wellcome the upcoming future of docsis 4.0 cable internet with 10G internet technology that will come soon probably in couple of years.

Related products

For small to medium homes need for mesh wifi system, you may consider affordable TP-link Deco x68 ax3600 mesh wifi, or you may try new Orbi rbk763 or deco xe75 pro.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *